Evaluation is the process of determining if a project or service does what it says on the tin and to determine if it is making the hoped-for impact. During an evaluation it is necessary to look at what difference the project planned to achieve, and to look at details like who experiences the change and how long the project takes. It will look at the progress towards outcomes (changes) such as ‘has this project improved the mental health of its participants’. It will look at what is going well, what needs to be improved (or can be learned from in the case of completed projects) and how the project could make a bigger difference before it finishes. It may also include a cost-benefit analysis.
When charities and non-profits are planning for their evaluation projects, they need to consider whether they use an internal or external approach or maybe a combination of both would be the best option. Each has benefits and weaknesses that depend on the organisation’s goals, resources and participants.
Internal Evaluations – conducted by the charity or non-profit organisation itself using internal staff, systems and processes.
Benefits of internal evaluations include:
- Cost-effective – Using internal staff avoids the expense of hiring in consultants or evaluators therefore saving you some money.
- Immediate insights – Internal teams are sometimes more easily able to monitor progress and impact in real-time, allowing for quicker assessments, adjustments and improvements to the project.
- Easily tailored – Any measurement frameworks used can be easily tailored in-house to the charity’s size, goals, values and mission.
- Staff learning – Internal projects can lean towards a culture of learning within the organisation, getting staff into the habit of reflecting and evaluating as they go. This can also keep staff more engaged in the life-cycle of a charity.

External Evaluations – conducted by a third-party evaluator or consultant from outside the charity or organisation
Benefits of external evaluations include:
- Expertise – External evaluators bring a huge wealth of knowledge and specialised expertise in data collection, analysis and reporting. They will use well-practiced and robust methodologies for an accurate report.
- Impartiality – With credibility and objectivity external evaluators are more impartial, this can build trust with funders, partners and the public creating transparency for your organisation. This can benefit with fundraising and advocacy because being able to demonstrate impact can be a powerful tool for attracting funding and influencing policy.
- Accountability – External evaluations help to meet funder or regulatory requirements for transparency and effectiveness.
- Provides a critical friend – It’s often easier to see the big picture if you are removed from the daily-grind or personal investment of a project.
- Additional capacity – Often internal staff do not have the capacity to complete evaluations as well as their day-to-day roles, leading to delayed reporting.
“Having an external monitoring and evaluation facility has been invaluable and, going forward, we would be looking to include this in any new service bids. The impartial, yet well-versed, approach has allowed us to ensure our funders are educated as well as satisfied by our endeavours.
The addition of The Charity Spark’s findings/observations gives our work more gravitas than it would otherwise have and it has been refreshing working with talented and committed people who want the best for our client group.” Mark Taylor, Director of Operations, SPEAR

The Charity Spark are able to provide your organisation with a great, clear evaluation to help you determine which strategies are working and which are not. Using this evaluation, we can help to support your organisation’s strategic development as well as improving funder reporting, impact reports and the engagement of your collaborators, community groups and interested partners.
Get in touch today to find out more about how we can support your evaluation project hello@thecharityspark.co.uk