It has been several months since the world held its breath as the Notre Dame burned in Paris. Many other tragedies have occurred since then – we’ve seen the refugee crisis continue in the Mediterranean, the Amazon rainforest burn and recently, hurricane storms hit the Caribbean.
Soon after the fire struck the famous French landmark, I wrote an article about six things the subsequent fundraising campaign taught us about fundraising.
Significantly, we’ve now heard that some donors to the Notre Dame fund (both high profile and anonymous) have refused to pay their pledged donations because;
‘they want to know exactly what their money will be spent on before they hand it over, and not just pay employees’ salaries’ states Andre Finot, the Senior Press Official at Notre Dame.
This raises an interesting point and one that seems to be increasingly referred to by donors; individuals and foundations alike.
How much should a donor be able to caveat their donation and when should they trust that the organisation will use their money appropriately and effectively?
It also brings to the forefront the hotly debated ‘core costs vs project costs’. A restoration project like the Notre Dame is an enormous undertaking. One that needs excellent, world-class heritage restoration professionals not to mention project management, fundraising, operations, finance, communications, governance and public relations experts. Many of whom would not have already been employed, or budgeted for, by Notre Dame before the fire.
As a fundraiser, it is often a frustrating distinction to have to draw a line between ‘core’ costs and ‘project’ costs in order to please a funder. Many funders won’t consider salaries or governance, and won’t want to fund further fundraising to support the strategic future of the charity or see their money going to rent and operational costs.
They want the money to go solely on running the life-changing or highly visible projects which are satisfyingly identifiable.
The thing is, without the charity running the projects, training its staff, evaluating its impact, staying legal; the project will not run and it certainly won’t be successful.
It is important to say here that I firmly believe charities should be fully transparent with how they spend their money and should strive to keep core operating costs to an efficient yet effective level. It is right and proper that we hold charities accountable with how much of the money given to them, or generated by them, is being spent directly on its charitable activities that are their core purpose. However, we shouldn’t be naïve enough to suggest that charity professionals shouldn’t have funded posts or that keeping a charity running is not a noble reason to donate.
To come back to the latest in the Notre Dame restoration, we see that major high profile donors who were very happy to accept the public attention for their donations are now resisting their money being spent unless it has been signed off by them. The cynic in me wants to suggest that perhaps they are looking for a stained-glass window or aisle to be named after them but one hopes that it isn’t quite so egotistical.
What the Friends of Notre Dame foundation have said is that the project, repair and restoration work that has happened so far has been funded by the smaller donations that flooded in from across the world – many from the United States. As with many charities, our smaller individual donors give without restrictions, often through online giving, and with full faith that their money will be put to good work by the organisation responsible. These donors don’t receive accolades or get stained glass windows named after them (although many a capital campaign has been propped up by ‘name a brick’ appeals) – they simply give, to a cause they have an emotional connection to and one which they have full faith will be restored to its former glory.
Four fundraising lessons charities can take from the Notre Dame campaign:
1. The power of the small donation.
Every little adds up. It would be fascinating to see the number of donations and the average amount once you take out the major pledges from the Notre Dame campaign. Don’t neglect your individual donors, they are on just as much of a journey with your cause as your major donors are. It might not feel that their donation will transform your project but the power of many smaller donations can make an enormous (unrestricted!) impact.
2. Restricting funds can be dangerous.
When we make exacting and stringent promises to donors about how their major donation will be spent, we risk over-restricting the funds within a project and creating complex approval cycles which put far too much power in the donors hands. Whilst we want to ensure a donor feels part of the project and comfortable with how their money is spent, we should focus our time on building trust and understanding with the philanthropist so they feel confident the money will be spent how it can be most impactful for the cause, rather than simply to massage an ego.
3. Core costs and salaries are not dirty words!
Charities will not run unless the lights are on, salaries are paid and the insurances are up to date. These might not be sexy costs that light up a donors world but they are essential to the charity’s effectiveness and sustainability. Instead of avoiding talking about core costs, ensure that your operation is confident in communicating how it operates and transparent in what it spends. If you want good, competent staff you are going to have to pay them – unfortunately not many people are privileged enough to volunteer for a living. Many of the general public have quite polarised opinions on charity staff salaries. Of course they shouldn’t be obscene either but if you compare a senior CEO salary in the charity sector to an equivalent size (and turnover) organisation in the private sector, you’ll be surprised at how different they are even if it seems ‘high for a charity’. Don’t shy away from having these conversations with your major donors, preferably before the point at which they pledge.
4. Be careful with your wording.
Whether you are talking to a potential major donor or someone looking to pledge £20, be careful with the wording you use in your fundraising messaging. Swap ‘will’ for ‘could’ in your price propositions. ‘£20 could provide a night in a domestic violence refuge for one person’ does not restrict the donation to only being used for that purpose. ‘£20 will provide a night in a domestic violence refuge’ does restrict the donation. This isn’t about dishonesty or trying to trick anyone – always be clear that examples you give of how the charity spend their money are true costs but that donations will be used to meet any charitable expenses over the next financial year. Your donors will respect you for it and your accountant will stop twitching!
According to the Notre Dame press reports, the Philanthropists contacted have all said they do intend to make good on their original pledges. I certainly feel for the Philanthropy team working hard behind the scenes to get the cheques signed and hope that they are successful in negotiating terms.
Articles referenced:
USA Today: French billionaires didn’t rebuild Notre Dame, small donors did
Metro: Billionaires haven’t paid a cent towards Notre Dame despite pledging millions