I first published this post on LinkedIn where it started an interesting debate – see it in its original form and join the discussion on LinkedIn.
This week it was deeply saddening to watch the Notre-Dame burn. A cathedral that has stood for hundreds of years and survived two World Wars unscathed, was devastated within a matter of hours as fire ripped through the building toppling its spire.
Within 48 hours, over €1 billion has been donated to the restoration of the cathedral in Paris. Donations have poured in from wealthy people and businesses from around the world. In the case of one individual donor, a pledge of €100 million was forthcoming by the end of the first 24 hours.
The irony is not lost on those amongst the Cathedral community who, before the fire, struggled to raise funds for the most basic of repairs and discussions had been started around charging visitors an entry fee in order to generate an income.
It is certainly one of the fastest growing fundraising campaigns that we have seen and has raised eyebrows throughout the Charity sector as fundraisers tirelessly campaign to raise funds for projects which will change lives in their communities and further afield but receive far less support than we have seen in the last few days so what does #SaveNotreDame tell us about major donor and campaign fundraising?
First up, the positives:
1. It’s got to be personal (and proximity helps)
When a cause is deeply personal and rooted in patriotism or long-held beliefs, we see donors act. When I ran the London Marathon in 2012, I chose to run for the Down’s Syndrome Association. My youngest sister has DS and so the cause was personal, not just for me but for my family and friends. The women who participate in the Cancer Research ‘Race for Life’ or those who hold a Macmillan coffee morning have undoubtedly experienced personally or through relationships close to them, the devastating effect of Cancer. When we identify personal connections to donors, we find they are willing to help. Whether this is a community fundraiser, a challenge event participant or a major donor, you can bet that they will be united by a desire to support a cause that resonates personally. When I worked for a small international development charity, the personal connection for one donor wasn’t that they too had been a refugee or displaced from their home but simply that they had children and their emotional connection to a mother trying to keep their child safe was the driving factor for that individual to donate. What we see with Notre-Dame is that buildings, religion and art can evoke emotional and personal reactions – from those French nationals who see Notre-Dame as a patriotic symbol to those who have worshipped within her walls, their donations are part of their emotional response to the cause. When we seek new donors, are we always looking to build on the personal, emotional connections that they may have with our cause? Are we tailored and deliberate enough?
2. A clear solution is important: ‘contribute ‘x’ and ‘y’ will result’
We need to acknowledge that for some of us, our charitable aims are pretty big and can feel quite abstract. That is why we are far more effective in our communication when we talk in terms of specific outcomes and change that will be made in communities or within our charity’s remit. Most donors want to know what their money will actually do. Of course there are some who are creative thinkers who are emotionally drawn to ‘imagine a world without….’ but this is usually due to an existing personal connection with the cause (see point 1!) meaning they have a real visceral feeling of what it means for a solution to be found. For most, a tangible change as a result of their donation is important. Notre-Dame has burned down, President Macron has promised that it will be rebuilt with the money donated within five years and in time for the 2024 Paris Olympics. That is a real clear solution with an almost touchable result. The donors can see what the direct result of their giving will be and it is exciting to them. As fundraisers we need to be clever about finding those moments, projects and (dare I say it) products that provide a direct, timely and relevant response to their donation. For many of us this may be as simple as ensuring we have a creative and effective supporter journey which provides impact reporting as well as the all-important thank you.
3. The money is out there
For a moment, let us put aside the pitchforks and cries of ‘that much money for a building?!’. Let’s be realistic, being able to get tax relief on charitable donations is not new yet it hasn’t driven these individuals and companies to donate hundreds of millions of Euros in one go previously. If ‘they are donating for the tax relief’ was true, then we’d see far more large donations annually. What these immediate, impulsive donations show us is that there is money out there which, given the right circumstances, could be given to charitable activity. As a fundraiser, it can sometimes feel like you have to jump through hoops backwards all whilst wearing a fairy outfit on a Tuesday during a full moon, in order to get a donor to pledge money to your cause. Sometimes cries of ‘what more do they need to know?!’ fill the office and you wonder how many more heart-wrenching stories you need to find from your delivery team to convince someone that their money will make an enormous difference. What we can take from the Notre-Dame fundraising is that there remain organisations and individuals globally who have the ‘disposable’ funds to make an enormous impact on the projects they feel most passionately about. That is a good thing.
4. Acknowledgement is important
Acknowledgement, thanks and ‘we couldn’t do it without you’ is not always about massaging egos or being public with who our donors are but it is important. It is about reinforcing that personal connection, keeping our donors feeling valued and recognising that as a Charity, we are reliant on people just like them. Acknowledgement forms part of our supporters’ journey with us and whilst in the case of Notre-Dame the world’s media have begun that process, we can be sure that there will be much to follow in order to acknowledge and thank those who have contributed.
Then there are three points that are less easy to swallow:
5. ‘Saviour’ syndrome is a thing
We have to recognise that for some, giving a donation is part of an ulterior motive rather than a simply self-less act. Whilst it isn’t nice to admit, being seen as the saviour of a situation and receiving the adulation that will undoubtedly follow can be all the more reason to give rather than so off-putting that a donor will choose to give anonymously. When something as big as the Notre-Dame fire takes hold of the world’s media attention, you will always find announcements of funding and donations that are part of the ‘need to be seen’. There is a reason why capital projects across the world carry the name of their donor, not always because that was an honour bestowed due to their generosity but often because it was a requirement of the donation being made. With the publicity received by those donating to Notre-Dame, we see part of the more egotistical side of major giving both from corporates and individuals as well as the tax-efficiencies. As charities and fundraisers, we have to decide what is right for our cause and our future fundraising.
6. It isn’t always rational
The hardest thing to swallow is that there are so many disasters which take life, displace families, destroy historic sites and have a long-lasting impact on people which are not supported in this way by donors.
We also recognise that there are lots of other charities who don’t work within the immediate crisis response sector but who do equally valuable work across the world who struggle to raise funds for their cause. That whilst people go hungry, children are unsafe and the environment suffers, over a billion Euros has been raised to save one building.
I certainly admit to wishing that donors were as generous as this towards other fundraising campaigns but we see with Notre-Dame that giving isn’t always rational. The same goes for the media attention – where are they when communities despair at home and abroad? Where are they when families face devastation? When historical sites around the world fall victim to war?
But then we realise that we have to put our causes before our own frustrations, learn from this what we can and apply it to our fundraising so that we can be part of the solution.