Notice: Function Elementor\Core\Experiments\Manager::warn_removed_or_hidden_dependency was called incorrectly. Feature mega-menu depends on hidden experiment nested-elements. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 4.4.1.) in /home/u63711/domains/thecharityspark.co.uk/public_html/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6260
‘Silenced Voices’: Engaging Marginalised Groups in Evaluation Research – The Charity Spark

‘Silenced Voices’: Engaging Marginalised Groups in Evaluation Research

Written by Andrea Martinez

In evaluation research, the importance of inclusivity cannot be overstated. To truly understand the impact of programmes and initiatives, it is crucial to engage with all members of society, especially those from marginalised groups. These groups are often vulnerable, excluded, or reluctant to participate in research. They include racial and ethnic minorities, individuals with disabilities, low-income communities, women, LGBTQ+ populations, non-English speakers, individuals experiencing homelessness, and those with limited access to resources and limited possibilities to change their situation. This blog aims to provide a comprehensive guide on how to effectively involve and empower marginalised communities in the evaluation process.

  1. Understand the context. Prior to interacting with any client or community, it is crucial to grasp their historical, cultural, and social background. This involves delving into their experiences, values, beliefs, and needs, as well as recognising the challenges and barriers they encounter. 
  2. Build trust and establish relationships. The foundation of successful engagement lies in building trust. Establishing authentic relationships based on trust and mutual respect with members of marginalised communities is essential. This involves spending time within the community, listening to their concerns, and demonstrating a genuine commitment to understanding their experiences.
  3. Gain cultural competence. It is imperative for researchers to be culturally competent. This involves having a deep understanding of the cultural nuances, histories, and contexts of the marginalised group being studied. This knowledge helps in crafting research approaches that are respectful and culturally sensitive.
  4. Be mindful of your biases and assumptions. Reflect on your own positions, beliefs and relationships and try to understand how these factors may affect your interactions with marginalised groups. This is the researcher’s positionality (Moree, 2018) which entails an awareness that encourages both personal reflection and responsible decision-making. Through thorough research and self-reflection, you can steer clear of stereotyping, stigmatising, or passing judgment. Instead, approach them with a mindset of curiosity, humility, and respect.
  5. Use community-based participatory research (CBPR). CBPR is an approach that involves collaboration between researchers and community members in all aspects of the research process. This involves acknowledging their agency, autonomy, and dignity, and fostering their ability to make choices and determine their own path. By involving the community in the design, implementation, and dissemination of research, CBPR ensures that the study is relevant and beneficial to the community.
  6. Use inclusive and accessible language. Evaluation research materials should be presented in language that is accessible and inclusive. Avoiding jargon and using plain language (without patronising) helps ensure that everyone can understand and engage with the research findings.
  7. Employ flexible and inclusive research methods: Traditional research methods may not always be suitable for marginalied communities. Utilise a mix of quantitative and qualitative methods, and be open to innovative approaches that better capture the experiences of the community. This may include storytelling, art-based methods, or digital storytelling.
  8. Address power imbalance. Acknowledge and address power imbalances between researchers and the community. Empower community members to be active participants in the research process rather than passive subjects (.e.g doing with not doing to). This can be achieved through capacity-building and training programmes. Explicitly acknowledging the experiential knowledge of marginalised groups is also empowering.
  9. Uphold ethical considerations. Pay close attention to ethical considerations when working with marginalised groups. Obtain informed consent, prioritise confidentiality, and ensure that the research benefits the community rather than exploiting their vulnerabilities.
  10. Use trauma-informed approaches. Many members of marginalised groups may have experienced trauma. A trauma-informed approach involves recognising the widespread impact of trauma, understanding the signs, and creating a safe and supportive environment for research participants.
  11. Share findings. Ensure that the findings are disseminated back to the community in a way that is accessible and meaningful. This might involve community presentations, workshops, or creating easily digestible reports.
  12. Engage in continuous reflection. Regularly reflect on the research process and be willing to adapt. Seek feedback from the community and use it to refine your approach. Continuous improvement is essential for building trust and ensuring that the research is truly beneficial.

By adopting these suggested approaches, researchers can contribute to a more equitable and just understanding of the impact of programmes and policies on all members of society. Remember, empowering marginalised communities in the research process not only enhances the quality of the study but also promotes social justice and equity.

References:

Baur, V. E., Abma, T. A., & Widdershoven, G. A. (2010). Participation of marginalized groups in evaluation: Mission impossible? Evaluation and program planning, 33(3), 238-245.

Moree, D. (2018). Qualitative approaches to studying marginalized communities. In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Education.

Potnis, D., & Gala, B. (2020). Best practices for conducting fieldwork with marginalized communities. Information Processing & Management, 57(3), 102144.