Notice: Function Elementor\Core\Experiments\Manager::warn_removed_or_hidden_dependency was called incorrectly. Feature mega-menu depends on hidden experiment nested-elements. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 4.4.1.) in /home/u63711/domains/thecharityspark.co.uk/public_html/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6260
Building a diverse trustee board: the essentials – The Charity Spark

Building a diverse trustee board: the essentials

community gardening project with banner over image saying 'building a diverse trustee board: the essentials"

‘Am I the right woman for your board?’ – the importance of a diverse trustee board

A charity trustee board should be diverse, in order to represent the community they serve.

This means including people from all walks of life, with different skills and backgrounds. By doing so, you can make informed decisions about where to allocate your resources.

Recently I was approached to sit on a trustee board, and I asked the chair why he had asked me; ‘because we felt like additional female representation would be helpful’ was the answer. ‘But why me? Am I the RIGHT woman for your board?’.  I asked this for several reasons – I am a white, British, middle-class woman who is educated to degree-level. I am not a beneficiary of their organisation and have no direct experience of the type of issue they support people with. The rest of their board were 90% male, white and middle-class British.  I could have been the daughter of any one of them.  I asked again ‘am I the RIGHT woman for your board?’.  Yes, I could bring value and insight particularly in terms of charity management and strategy. Yes, I am an empath and would work hard to understand the needs of the beneficiary group. But there will always be a limit to my understanding.

I praised the board for wanting to diversify but gently guided them in how they might seek to do so.  They needed good representation of their beneficiary group, they needed a more ethnically diverse trustee board and they needed to gain some specialised expertise from a clinician or academic in the relevant field.

In this case, I really felt like I would be a token of a desire to diversify and not actually a very good solution for their need.

Images shows five people having a  meeting of diverse trustees

1. The importance of a diverse board

There are several reasons why it’s important to have a diverse board. It allows different voices to be heard, which can help with making informed decisions and prevent stale leadership by injecting fresh ideas into discussions. Through diversification, more effective relationships can be nurtured with the community you serve, as they can see that you’re committed to including them in your work which builds confidence and helps accountability. Finally, having a diverse board can also help to attract new donors and supporters as it opens up the network of the charity to a wider spread of potential supporters and donors, who are able to better connect with an organisation operating with a diverse mindset.

When it comes to making important decisions about where to allocate your resources, it’s important to have a board that represents the community. This can also help to build strong relationships between the charity and the community, which is essential for long-term success. This means having people from all walks of life, with different skills and backgrounds. Diversity on your board will allow you to make informed decisions based on a variety of perspectives.

The Charity Commission in the UK released data that illustrates the lack of diversity in our trustee boards. According to the Taken on Trust research (2017) 92% of trustees are white. Men dominate the board room with seven out of ten trustees being male and the median age is 61 years. The research points out a lack of diversity in age as well as gender and race, with only 0.5% of the trustee population made up of 18-24-year-olds.

2. Making informed decisions about where to allocate resources

Diversity opens up viewpoints and experiences that you may not have ever considered or been exposed to, but which are essential to consider when developing an accessible, inclusive and diverse organisation.

The community you serve is likely to be more trusting of a board that represents them and can understand, first hand, the experiences which they face. A more diverse board can also benefit those who use your services. Having a board that represents the community you serve can help to ensure that your services are meeting the needs of those who use them.

Allocating resources in a beneficiary-first, participatory way is important in effective charities and this is made possible by a diverse board who can champion different parts of your community as well as elevate the beneficiary voice at all times.

Unconscious bias exists in all of us and increased diversification of trustee boards together with self-awareness helps to identify where such bias exists so that it can be avoided.

Image shows five people from diverse backgrounds having  a meeting

3. Ways you can create diversity on your board

There are a few ways you can create diversity on your board:

1. Recruit from different professional backgrounds and sectors

One way to create diversity on your board is to proactively recruit trustees from different backgrounds and sectors. This will help to ensure that the board has a variety of skills and experiences that can be helpful in making informed decisions about where to allocate resources. The old saying ‘if you do what you’ve always done, you’ll get what you’ve always got’ is important to remember. Think about where you advertise trustee positions, who you speak to and how you can reach groups of people who are not currently represented at board level. The Charity Commission research estimates that 81% of trsutees are recruited through word of mouth, reducing the number of people who will know that a trustee role is open and limiting it to those already in your personal networks.

If you’re unsure where to start, talk to a specialist charity recruiter such as Charisma Recuritment or trustee recruitment specialists such as Trustees Unlimited or Getting On Board. Treat this as a job recruitment, what is the aim? What key skills and/or experiences are you looking for? What might prospective trustees need to know about the organisation?

2. Encourage applications from under-represented groups

Another way to create diversity on your board is to encourage applications from under-represented groups by considering the barriers to participation. To encourage applications from under-represented groups you may need to consider what barriers to entry there are:

a) what time are your trustee meetings? If they are always in the working day you may find people of working age find it hard to commit.

b) what costs might someone incur by being a trustee? Whilst trustees are volunteers, organisations should offer to cover their expenses. This is particularly important if you are going to be able to diversify your trustee board in a way that doesn’t cause candidates financial difficulty. Can you offer travel costs or cover childcare for trustee meetings?

c) how can you improve visibility of your trustee vacancies? Network with community members and beneficiaries who use your projects, ask them to share that you are looking for a trustee. Do they know what it means to be a trustee? What is the time commitment? Can you make reasonable adjustments to support new trustees into their role. Perhaps offering to cover the costs of a training course which introduces trustee responsibilities. Make it less scary!

d) consider having a standing beneficiary trustee role. This could be a trustee position that rotates each year and is always filled by a beneficiary but doesn’t require them to commit for a long term.

Community gardening project with diverse trustees

3. Consider different types of diversity

It’s also important to consider different types of diversity when creating a more diverse board. This includes things like age, socio-economic background, disability, education, and life experiences. By considering all forms of diversity, you can ensure that the board is truly representative of the community you serve. Do you have women, people of colour, LGBTQIA+ individuals, and people with disabilities on your board? If you only recruit men from your beneficiary group you are still limiting the diversity of the board and therefore gaining only narrow representation even if they have some differing life experiences from the rest of your board.

When a board commits to welcoming all people and perspectives it grows a healthy organisation; it inspires creativity, encourages collaboration, and increases empathy, creating more inclusion.

Summary

A diverse board is important in order to make informed decisions and maintain relevance as an organisation. There are a few ways you can create diversity on your board, and we hope that this blog post has given you some ideas for how to start thinking about it.

As well as considering different types of diversity when creating a more diverse board, consider what barriers there might be to participation and how you can overcome them. By doing this, you can ensure that the board is truly representative of the community you serve.

If you would like to learn more about trustee recruitment or have any questions, please get in touch with us at hello@thecharityspark.co.uk